Category Archives: Georgian

The Body in the Ice by A.J. MacKenzie

Zaffre | 2017 (20 April) | 342p | Review copy | Buy the book

The Body in the Ice by AJ MacKenzieIt is Christmas Day in 1795 and this is one of the coldest winters that people can remember. But the villagers of St Mary in the Marsh in Kent will have more reason than most to remember this particular Christmas – a body is discovered, frozen into the ice of a horse pond belonging to New Hall, the deserted grand house on the edge of the village. It’s not, though, as deserted as it should have been. Two men were spotted arriving there a couple of days before but both have now vanished. Reverend Hardcastle, justice of the peace as well as rector, doesn’t delay in pursuing these men but it’s not long before he realises that there is more to the murder mystery than first appeared. And matters are compounded when New Hall’s owners arrive to reclaim their ancestral home, years after abandoning it for new lives in America.

This is a time of unease. Peace has finally been achieved with America after the Revolution and independence but Britain is at war with France and this vulnerable Kent coast feels the threat more than most. And so Hardcastle and his friend and neighbour Amelia Chaytor will receive little help from the preoccupied authorities for their investigations, especially after an obvious suspect makes himself known. But, as the winter continues to hold its grip, Hardcastle is convinced that all is not as it seems.

The Body in the Ice is the second Hardcastle and Chaytor historical mystery by A.J. MacKenzie but, I’m sorry to say, it’s my first. There are links to the first novel The Body on the Doorstep but that didn’t affect my enjoyment or understanding of The Body in the Ice at all. The story stands alone very well and I was gripped from its opening icey chapter, immediately falling for Amelia and the rector (and the dog, even the rector’s sister). But, if you do want to read The Body on the Doorstep, make sure you read that first.

I love historical murder mysteries, especially those that evoke strong feeling for the times in which they’re set, and The Body In the Ice does just that with the American Wars of Independence and the war with France playing their part. I hadn’t thought before about the impact of the American revolution on families in Britain, many of whom would have been divided, but this novel brings that to the fore. But there are other big themes here, such as the treatment of black men and women on both sides of the Atlantic during these days of slavery.

But apart from all the tension and drama of the murder mystery (which is excellent), there is humour, mostly at the expense of the rector’s poor sister, Cordelia. She is a gothic novelist (currently engaged in writing The Lighthouse of Vavassal) and not above providing generous writing advice to the sister of a new arrival in the village, Captain Edward Austen from Hampshire. But Cordelia complements Amelia perfectly and I enjoyed them both.

The Body in the Ice evokes a world of Georgian country villages that revolve around their church and manor house, with a dash of smuggling thrown in as this is the Kentish coast. It is richly atmospheric and wonderfully written, with just the right proportions of domestic and national politics, murder and polite conversation. The ending put me on the edge of my seat – there comes a time when manners have to be put to one side. I will most definitely be following this series from now on. I’m looking forward to The Body in the Boat very much.

A Death at Fountains Abbey by Antonia Hodgson

A Death at Fountains Abbey | Antonia Hodgson | 2016 (25 August) | Hodder & Stoughton | 356p | Review copy | Buy the book

A Death at Fountains Abbey by Antonia HodgsonTom Hawkins wants nothing more than to take a well-earned continental break with his ‘wife’ Kitty, leaving the pitfalls of London and their pornographic book business behind. George II’s Queen Caroline, though, has other plans for Tom and there’s not much he can do about it, considering that she knows more than enough about him and Kitty to see them hang at the end of a noose – again. Queen Caroline has received letters from ex-Treasurer Mr John Aislabie stating that his life is in danger and he is in need of protection. This is hardly surprising news. As the man responsible for the financial cataclysm that was the South Sea Bubble, half of England wants John Aislabie dead. The fact that the Queen sends Tom off to Aislabie’s estate in Yorkshire is a fair enough indication of how highly she values Aislabie’s life. At least it’s a break from London.

Tom and Kitty find a household in disorder. Aislabie’s past has come back from the dead to haunt him and there’s no way to know if this is connected to the death threats. It’s all an unwelcome diversion from Aislabie’s main passion (except for horses), which is to transform his estate in the latest style (for the late 1720s) and take over the next door property which has a rather pleasing ruin in its grounds – Fountains Abbey.

A Death at Fountains Abbey is the third adventure for Tom Hawkins and, like the others, it can be read as a stand alone, apart from a few light references to events from the previous novel, The Last Confession of Thomas Hawkins. Tom is attempting to turn over a new leaf a he makes a life with the irresistible and slightly dangerous Kitty and he’s probably pleased to leave his gambling and drinking haunts safely behind in London. But he can’t leave it all behind. Sam, the son of one of London’s chief gang captains, comes along as Tom’s ears and eyes. I can’t imagine one of these novels without Sam. I was so pleased he came along, although I don’t think he cared for the Yorkshire countryside very much.

The mystery at the heart of the novel is set against the grand background of a country estate that is in the process of reshaping itself according to the local fashion. Much of it is more or less a building site but there are still plenty of outdoor pursuits to enjoy (so long as not all the deer are slaughtered as gruesome warnings to Aislabie). London seems a long way away – reflecting Aislabie’s desires to leave his sins and disgrace behind. Tom finds himself in a world that is still feudal despite the spread of fashionable ideas and, although he is now far removed from the prisons of London, the penal system continues as a theme in A Death at Fountains Abbey.

Antonia Hodgson works her sources wonderfully (I loved the notes at the end of the book) and, as usual, sprinkles the story with real historical figures while creating a mystery that does them credit. Indeed, most of the characters here are historical, including Aislabie, right down to his cook, the builders and his troublesome tenants. Antonia Hodgson takes a few mentions of such figures from contemporary accounts and breathes life into them, making them every bit as three-dimensional as Tom, Kitty and Sam, who, as always, are fabulous companions – always entertaining, most definitely not entirely or even a little respectable, brave, persistent and attractive (bar the odd scar). Tom and Kitty’s relationship is not typical in the slightest but it’s a lot of fun to observe. As events here take place in a country estate there is an attempt at least to maintain a veneer of manners, particularly at the regular formal dinner, but this is clearly not even skin deep. Putting your foot in it every time you open your mouth is a trait that many of the characters in this novel have perfected.

I must confess that I did miss the London setting of the previous two novels. London was such a prominent character, as were the prisons. The stench and cruelty of the prisons and rookeries of London added a darkness and grim realism to the previous novels which is missing in A Death At Fountains Abbey. Fountains Abbey, despite the murder and mayhem, is a lighter story and the setting calmer. But Tom and Kitty deserve their respite after all that they’ve endured and, even though they manage to place themselves in as much peril as ever, there’s a strong sense that they’re enjoying the roles they’ve chosen to play. I love Antonia Hodgson’s slightly wicked sense of humour and it’s put to good use here and her clear affection for Tom and Kitty and Sam, as well as her enthusiasm for the period, is infectious. This is such a strong series and I hope it goes on and on.

Other review
The Last Confession of Thomas Hawkins

Mathew’s Tale by Quintin Jardine

Mathew’s Tale | Quintin Jardin | 2014 (Pb 2015) | Headline | 360p | Review copy | Buy the book

Mathew's Tale by Quentin JardineIn 1818, after seven long years, Mathew Jardine returns home from war to Lanarkshire in Scotland, a hero of the Battle of Waterloo. The cost has been great – one eye is gone, half his face scarred and another scar shows where a sword pierced his liver and almost claimed his life. In fact, Mathew returns home a ghost. His exhausted, well-meaning captain had believed the doctors when they said Mathew would die and so he wrote Mathew’s mother and betrothed a letter that would break their hearts. Mathew always loved Lizzie but returning home, believed a dead man, he finds her married to another man and near ready to give birth. But Mathew is a deeply principled, honourable man. Instead of turning against Lizzie’s husband David, he chooses to befriend him, slowly forming another of those close relationships that distinguishes Mathew’s life. But Mathew isn’t just a kind and reasonable man, he is also a warrior, a man who has killed, and it is that side of him that knows he can never forgive the Cleland twins, Gregor and Gavin, the local lords, for their behaviour towards his family and the men who work their land.

Mathew is an ‘Iron Baron’, one of the new businessmen who knows how to profit from the rise of the Industrial Revolution. He has the magic touch. He is soon a wealthy, influential and important man, living a life to rival, even surpass, that of the Cleland baronets. When tragedy strikes, Mathew has to choose between the sword or legal justice, always conscious of his responsibility towards others. But vengeance will be had, however long it takes, and it is that quest for vengeance that forms Mathew’s tale.

Mathew’s Tale is a thoroughly engaging novel with a central character in Mathew who is completely captivating. It starts quietly enough as we learn of Mathew’s war and journey home but the quality of the prose, which feels authentically early 19th-century and has such a skilled lightness about it, sucks the reader in and it becomes an addictive read. I really struggled to put this book down. I became completely caught up in this story of Mathew, Lizzie, David and Mathew’s mother. Each of the characters is fully rounded, their dialogue presented in varying degrees of Scottish dialect, and they are each surrounded by a host of other more minor, always fascinating, figures who make up this vividly-depicted historical world.

Quite apart from the plot, which is never less than engrossing, the book’s appeal lies in the masterly ease with which Quintin Jardine portrays the historical setting, the Scottish location and early 19th-century society and law. This is a fascinating time, with the old feudal ways co-existing with an emerging industrial society. Men such as Mathew can rise from a considerably lowly status – in the army as well as in life in general – and they can outshine the oldest families. Money takes on aristocratic lineage and new wealth can have a lot more clout than old. Of course, if you’re unfortunate enough to have neither new or old money, then you need to watch out. Life is as cruel as ever for the poor. Mathew bridges old and new and, as a result, his tale is as much about the times as it is about the murder case. Both are gripping and wonderfully done.

Mathew’s Tale is full of colour, immersing the reader in a bygone age with deceptive ease. It is such a pleasure to read, its moral and social lessons never getting in the way of a fine story. Quintin Jardin has written a great many novels over the years – mostly modern crime fiction – and I’m sorry to admit that this is my first. This isn’t a period of history I’m naturally drawn to but once I started I did not want to stop. Mathew is a fabulous creation but there is more to Mathew’s Tale than just its leading figure. This is a highly accomplished, sensitive novel, enriched by great storytelling, characterisation and historical setting and mood. I absolutely loved it.

The Last Confession of Thomas Hawkins by Antonia Hodgson

The Last Confession of Thomas Hawkins | Antonia Hodgson | 2015, Pb 2016 | Hodder & Stoughton | 400p | Review copy | Buy the book

The Last Confession of Thomas Hawkins by Antonia HodgsonIt is 1728 and Thomas Hawkins is in trouble again. Having narrowly escaped in one piece from Marshalsea Prison, he’s now about to have his neck stretched. Dragged out of Newgate Prison on a cart for his final journey, a cart that obligingly stops at an inn to allow the doomed man one last tipple, Tom is to be hung for murder. As the gallows get nearer and the crowd grows ever more enthusiastic and cheery, Tom spends his time wondering how he came to find himself in such a pretty mess. It’s a tale worth hearing, although it appears it may have an abrupt end.

The Last Confession of Thomas Hawkins continues the story of our eponymous hero begun with the outstanding The Devil in the Marshalsea. You don’t need to have read the first book to enjoy this new one but it adds considerably to the tale to see the development of characters to whom we’ve grown attached, most especially Tom himself but also his long-suffering love Kitty. Other people come and go through both the novels, there are plenty of familiar names, but these are more than matched by a whole new set of characters that make The Last Confession a distinct book of its own. So, in other words, you don’t need to have read Marshalsea first, but you should read it. The Last Confession does contain some spoilers for its predecessor but there are none here.

Not much has changed for Tom. He’s still a gambler, a bit of a rake and a young man who can’t stand still. Life is good for him. He and Kitty have some money, they’ve set up home together – as well as a pornography printing shop, which is doing very well – and ‘marriage’ is a concept that has begun to shimmer above the horizon, admittedly still a little out of reach. But Tom can’t help feeling a little bored and he’s all too ready to grasp the chance to do some meddling, most particularly as the eyes and ears of one of London’s most feared and violent gang lords (to whom Tom has a faint connection). Not satisfied with that, he also finds himself helping out none other than the Queen, whose lady in waiting has got herself into a tight spot as a direct result of being the King’s mistress. It’s a tangled – painfully high profile – affair to be sure. Stakes are high and blood will be spilt, a fear that comes to fruition when Tom’s neighbour is found murdered in his bed. In this world coincidences don’t exist. Which is a shame because Tom can be found at the heart of it all. Kitty is not amused.

As with The Devil in the Marshalsea, Antonia Hodgson richly evokes the colour, smells and squalour of London’s stews and rookeries, as well as the glamour and perfume of the drawing rooms and parlours of the wealthy. We’re immersed in a place of coffee bars, seedy shops and printing houses, police dungeons and prisons. We have all classes here from the very lowest, barefoot in the stinking alleys, to those closest to the crown, where corruption is every bit as ripe as it is in the streets. It is fantastically drawn, the prose is light with a strong authentic feel, this London seems very truly to be early 18th century, alien and exotic and yet still familiar with its placenames and landmarks that survive today.

The setting, location and prose might be wonderful but so too are the plot and characters. The Last Confession has a great plot that I would argue even outdoes the plot of Marshalsea. Now that we know Tom better the storyline is much less about him, crucial though he is to its development. This is a marvellously tangled web of secrets and lies and murder and sin. If only Tom would rise above it all. If only he hadn’t become involved in the first place. But we know Thomas Hawkins very well, he’s so beautifully drawn after all, and we know he can’t help himself.

Tom and Kitty are such fabulous, friendly characters and they’re a lot of fun when they’re together. There is enormous tenderness and love – not that they can always see it – and both are willing to sacrifice everything for the other. It’s a pleasure to spend time with these two. They both have faults, especially Tom who seems to accrue extra faults by the day, but that doesn’t stop us caring for them. It’s hard not to worry about them when you see the forces working against them. There are some truly terrible Dickensian villains in this novel. The crimes are brutal and violent, the terror is real. This is a novel to keep you on the edge of your seat, your fears well fuelled.

I’m not a big reader of historical fiction set during the Georgian period. It’s never been a time that interested me but Antonia Hodgson challenges all of that. Not only does she make me feel thoroughly immersed in the period but she also makes me want to find out more about it. She is to be congratulated for The Last Confession of Thomas Hawkins. The Devil in the Marshalsea is a superb novel that all fans of historical fiction should read and enjoy but The Last Confession is even better! It is a tremendous achievement. Antonia Hodgson is a fine writer indeed and will become, I sense, an increasingly significant one.