The Sudden Appearance of Hope by Claire North

The Sudden Appearance of Hope | Claire North | 2016, Pb 2017 | Orbit | 480p | Review copy | Buy the book

Sudden Appearance of Hope by Claire NorthWho is Hope Arden? That’s impossible to answer. You could share a laugh with her, a meal, spend a day, even a night with her and then if you turned your head away for just a minute you would still remember the time but you would remember it as time spent alone – Hope cannot be remembered. As a child, Hope was remembered by her parents, friends and teachers but, slowly, as time went by in her teenage years, they began to forget until finally Hope’s beloved mother, a remarkable woman who once crossed a desert on foot, became the last to forget Hope Arden.

Only existing in the moment presents all kinds of difficulties for a young person, for a person of any age – how do you get a reference? How can a surgeon operate on you when just a toilet break would mean that they would never return to the table? Finding somewhere to live, making friends, falling in love – these things all become impossible, yet longed for. Every day is filled with constant saddening reminders of one’s failure to be remembered. You can leave a trail of notes and photos, clues to your existence, but starting from scratch again and again is no way to live. Unless you become a thief, of course. A forgettable face can commit the perfect crime.

In The Sudden Appearance of Hope, Claire North once again creates an unusual, original leading character, someone who exists in the familiar world but perceives it entirely differently through their remarkable gift or curse. The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August depicted a character who time and time again relived his life, while in Touch we had someone who could transfer their life into the body of another with just a brush of skin against skin. And now we have Hope who, thanks to being infinitely forgotten, can suddenly appear and reappear in somebody’s life for the very first time.

There is another element to the novel, though. It’s not just about a thief who cannot be remembered, it is also about Perfection, an app that can take over a life, given access to every area of that life, including bank accounts, and awards points for every decision, behaviour and purchase that moves that person closer towards Perfection. Becoming Perfect – beautiful, wealthy, calm – opens up whole new areas of privilege, but at what cost? When someone that Hope cared for as a friend kills herself for not being able to achieve perfection, Hope discovers a direction and purpose for her criminal acts. She might not say as much (Hope is not one to tell us too much about her crimes) but, as the novel proceeds, we become well tuned to reading between the lines with Hope Arden.

We experience most of the novel through Hope’s eyes. She’s used to hiding much of what she thinks – the hurt at being forgotten by her parents isn’t easy to recover from. And we experience her coping mechanisms – the drive to define everything, to count everything. For most of the novel this works very well but I did find this becoming a little much during the final quarter as everything reaches its climax. It’s almost a stream of consciousness in some places and for the first time I found the book overlong. Nevertheless, for the most part, this narrative technique works well as we are utterly absorbed within the pain and challenge of being Hope Arden.

We’re given little time to get to know other characters in the novel but there are one or two that Hope becomes fascinated by, almost teasing to get some kind of lasting reaction, wanting to be remembered. There are other characters who are even as enigmatic as Hope herself. There is a strong mystery element to The Sudden Appearance of Hope and for much of the time Hope is as much in the dark as we are.

My favourite element of the book, though, is the world associated with Perfection. This ultimate app exerts an enormous power with such a force for corruption and I thought its depiction by Claire North to be every bit as original and fascinating as the creation of Hope. It could easily have been the subject of a novel on its own.

Hope is not an easy character to warm to. It’s hardly surprising. This is a woman who doesn’t experience the world as we do and yet how it makes her suffer. This is a deeply intriguing, clever novel, as I’ve come to expect from such an intriguing and clever author. When I hear of a new novel by Claire North I instantly want to read it. I know that I’ll be given something unusual, original, thought-provoking and memorable. I’ll remember Hope.

Other reviews
The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August

7 thoughts on “The Sudden Appearance of Hope by Claire North

  1. Tomcat

    I loved “The First Fifteen Lives of…” I think it was robbed of the Clarke Award last year. Claire North is an amazing stylist, with a great eye for historical and cultural detail.

    I liked “Touch” a fair bit, too, even if it did skew a little too closely to the narrative voice of the previous book.

    And so I’m a little skeptical about this one. I’m worried that North is falling into a rut of basically writing the same novel over and over: A hyper-realist exploration of a character with a radically personal supernatural circumstance/power. But I’m kinda reassured by your review. Probably will give it a go when a paperback appears. Nice ending to your review, too. 🙂

    1. Kate (For Winter Nights) Post author

      These are very special books and I know what you mean about the fear that a similar formula is repeated each time but I do find that once I read them that they’re very different. There’s more to Hope than the premise suggests and it’s those other bits that I enjoyed the most. This is much less superpowery. I did think this one was a little overlong – the last quarter was flabby. But it’s well worth reading and if you liked the other novels you’ll certainly enjoy this one. Thanks!

  2. Mogsy @ BiblioSanctum

    Thanks for this thoughtful review. I have only read Touch, and loved it…though I have a feeling she’s going to be a hit or miss author for me. I have high hopes for this one though, so I’m crossing my fingers that it’ll work for me 🙂 Starting it soon!

  3. Grab the Lapels

    This author sounds like she’s always looking for a new way to think about familiar problems. Ever feel like you recognize someone, but they can’t remember you? (chances are you had a class in college together!) Something like that.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.